Spoonbill Courier
home Marsh Creek Community Was FP&L to Blame For Higher Bills This Winter?

Was FP&L to Blame For Higher Bills This Winter?

On January 29 of this year, Spoonbill Courier posted a beef and warning about a sharp jump in the editor’s electric bill, and noted a recently-approved rate hike. Several subsequent comments pointed to the difficulty in pinning all the blame on FP&L. Even the editor owned up to some user responsibility. To perhaps settle it all, the daring and ever-thorough Gerry Kurth now takes a short deep dive into The Electric Bill to perhaps settle matters once and for all.

By Gerry Kurth

The Breakdown of Your FP&L Electricity Bill

1. Bill Components

Your FPL bill starts with a fixed $11 base charge covering metering, billing, and customer service — regardless of how much electricity you use. The two largest components are the energy charge (infrastructure, transmission, and distribution), roughly ~55% of your bill and the fuel charge (the pass-through cost of natural gas and other fuels to generate power, another ~25%. The remaining ~20% covers smaller riders like storm protection (~7%), environmental fees (~3%), conservation/capacity charges (~2%), and local taxes (~3–5%).

2. Usage Costs: Not Strictly Linear, But Close

FP&L uses a two-tier rate structure: lower per-kWh rates apply to the first 1,000 kWh, with slightly higher rates above that threshold. Since most average homes use 2,000+ kWh per month, the majority of customers encounter both tiers. The break is intended to conserve energy, but in practice, the difference is negligible. As a reference, the rough cost for us is about 14c/kWh. An average 2,500 sq.ft. house may consume 1,500 kwh, for a monthly bill of $210. Of course, big energy users like pool pumps, electric car charging, etc. will make that math meaningless.  

3. Rate Increases – The Buzz

In November 2025, the Florida Public Service Commission (PSC) approved a four-year settlement allowing FP&L to collect ~$6.9 billion in additional revenue from 2026–2029, funding grid upgrades, storm hardening, and solar investments. The widely cited “10% increase” refers specifically to the non-fuel base energy charge, not the total bill. For most residential customers, the real-world impact is less than $5. We’ll see similar increases through 2029.

4. Summer Heat and Bill Spikes

High summer temperatures push a typical home of 2,500 sq ft to 2,000–3,000+ kWh per month as air conditioning runs heavily. This can increase bills 25–50% or more over milder months. That increase far outweighs any rate adjustment.

5. Cold Fronts – The Hidden Bill Killer

In mild Florida winters, usage drops to 1,000–1,800 kWh as cooling needs ease. But during our cold snaps (lows in the 20s–40s°F), heat pumps lose efficiency and auxiliary electric strips will kick in, spiking usage. The AC unit turns into a giant toaster. Since our AC systems are optimized for cooling, heating costs are 2–3x more energy-intensive than cooling per degree, so a single cold front can hit harder than an entire hot summer month.

6. Takeaways

Thermostat management, whether manual or automatic is, as always , the big driver. But in addition, keep in mind that ….  

If your bill seems higher than expected, usage — not the rate adjustment — is the main driver.

Winter cold snaps can cause a much bigger billing surprise than a summer heat wave.

Pay attention to the dates of extreme weather versus your meter read date. A “surprise” bill is often the result of a cold snap that occurred weeks before the bill arrived.

7. PS

FPL offers the OnCall® program which uses a small energy-management device (the “cutoff device”) installed on your appliances to cycle them off during peak demand.

FP&L installs a small box on your AC, water heater, or pool pump. They can remotely cycle these off for short periods (usually 3–4 hours max) during high-demand events. Many long-term participants report going years without ever noticing a single activation. It is a “break glass in case of emergency” tool for the utility rather than a daily occurrence.

If you choose to join the program, you will receive fixed monthly credits on your bill regardless of whether FP&L actually activates the device. Savings are typically $100 per year.

You Might Also Like

4 thoughts on “Was FP&L to Blame For Higher Bills This Winter?

  1. “Solar investments”???
    Does that mean that we are spending money “investing” in solar panels? Solar panels are the worst thing for electricity production, and are bad for the environment and land use. They are almost as bad as wind farms. “Investing” in these systems is a total waste of money now, and later when they have to be replaced or removed.

  2. Well done Mr. Kurth.. We had a very unusual cold spell this winter and that always brings up comments about outrageous rate increases. You have slain that dragon once and for all. I’ve had the on-call device for years, who knows I probably saved 1 millions.😂😂

  3. Very helpful especially concerning the greater usage during cold weather – many thanks, Gerry.

Leave a Reply to David Gardner Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top